Clubtasting (gemiddelde score)
NAAM Score
Glen Rothes 1972 33Y Sherry Butt Signatory 97,7
Laphraoig  Càirdeas 97,3
Dalmore 1976 The Cross Hill 97,1
Ardbeg Corryvreckan 97,0
Lagavulin Distillers Edition 1990 96,8
Ardbeg Uigeadail 96,7
Ardbeg Supernova Committee Release 96,5
Glenfiddich 30Y 96,5
Rosebank 1990 Refill Sherry Butt Gordon & Macphail Cask Selection 96,5
Ardbeg Renaissance 96,3
Octomore 2.2 96,3
Talisker 25Y 96,2
Caol Ila 1984 23Y Exclusive Malts cask 2729 Madeira Hogshead 95,7
Knockando 21y Master Reserve 1986 95,3
The Balvenie 21Y Portwood 95,3
Glen Scotia 31Y Dun Bheagan 95,3
Caol Ila 1996 11Y Rum Finish Dun Bheagan 95,2
Laphroaig 15y 95,0
Highland Park Earl Magnus Edition One 15 Years Old 95,0
Port Ellen 6th Release 94,9
Laphroaig Quarter Cask 94,7
Talisker 18 Y 94,3
Tobermory 15Y ltd edition González Byass Oloroso Finish 94,1
Connemara Cask Strength Int. Malt Festival Gent 2010 93,7
Classic Of Islay Jack Wieber 93,5
Port Charlotte PC 8 93,4
Ardbeg Supernova Stellar Release 93,4
Glenlivet Nadurra 93,3
Glenkinchie 1987 19Y Hoghshead Signatory 93,0
Caol Ila 18y 93,0
Smokehead 93,0
Yamazaki 10Y 93,0
Glenlivet Nadurra 57,7° 92,8
Aberlour 15y Cuvée Marie d'Ecosee 92,7
Bruichladdich 1994 92,7
Milburn 27Y Sherry Finish Gordon & Macphail CC 1976 92,5
Glendronach 18Y 92,4
Bruichladich 3D3 92,3
Lagavulin 16 92,3
Arran 15th Anniversary Bottling Amontillado Sherry Finish 92,1
Port Askaig 17Y 92,1
Serendipity 92,1
Caol Ila 14y Chieftain's Hoghshead 92,0
Johnnie Walker Gold Label 92,0
Old Pulteney 17y 92,0
Highland Park 25y 91,8
Bowmore Enigma 12y 91,8
Bowmore 12 91,7
Teaninich 23y 1973 Rare Malts Select. 91,6
Benriach 1997 Whiskyfestival Gent 2009 91,3
Ardbeg 10 91,0
Auchentoshan Three Wood 91,0
Dalmore 12Y 91,0
Glenfiddich 18 91,0
The Balvenie Signature 91,0
Laphroaig Triple Wood 91,0
Dallas Dhu 26Y Rum Finish  Chieftain's 1979 90,9
Highland Park 1990 17Y Sherry Butt Signatory 90,9
Balblair 97 90,7
Linkwood 20Y Sherry Matured Douglas Laing OMC 1979 90,4
Aberfeldy 23Y Refill Hogshead Douglas Laing OMC 1978 90,3
Benromach Peat Smore 90,0
Bladnoch 1991 CS Gordon & Macphail 90,0
Macallan 10y Cask Strenth 90,0
Nikka Miyagikyo 15Y 89,9
Cardhu 12 89,7
Jura 10 89,3
Benromach 18y 89,0
Mortlach 1988 19Y Sherry Butt Signatory 88,9
Highland Park 18y 88,9
Yamazaki 12Y 88,1
Clynlish 14 88,0
Burn Of Speyside 87,3
Glenlivet 18y 87,0
Highland Park 12y 84,7
Auchroisk 13Y Chieftain's 1994 83,9
Balblair 16Y 82,9
Longmorn 13Y Dun Bheagan 1994 79,7
Whisky Live - Verviers (16/03/2008)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Dalmore King Aexander III 24 24 24 23 95
Ardmore 1990 17Y (Sigantory) 24 23 23 24 94
Ardbeg Airigh Nam Beist 23 23 23 24 93
Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban 23 24 23 23 93
Live Botteling Caol Ila 23 23 23 24 93
Aberfeldy 21 22 24 23 23 92
Bunnahabhain 9Y (Signatory) 23 21 24 24 92
Dalmore Gran Reserve 23 23 23 23 92
Glenfarclas 25 23 24 23 22 92
Laproaig CS 23 22 23 24 92
Talisker 18 23 23 23 23 92
Live Botteling Laproaig 22 22 24 23 91
Macallen Masters Edition 22 23 23 23 91
Yamazaki 12 22 23 23 23 91
Auchentoshan Three Wood 23 23 22 22 90
Caol Ila DE 22 22 24 22 90
Jura Heavy Peated 22 23 23 22 90
Live Botteling Ben Nevis 22 23 23 22 90
Macallan 18 22 23 23 22 90
Yamazaki 10 22 23 23 22 90
Glenmorangie Nectar 21 22 23 23 89
Jura 18 22 22 23 22 89
Macallan 15 22 22 22 23 89
Aberfeldy 12 22 22 22 22 88
Ardbeg Uigedail 22 22 22 22 88
Dewars 18 21 23 22 22 88
Glen Deveron 10 22 22 21 22 87
Yamazaki Hakuchu 22 21 21 23 87
Blanton Distillering Company Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky 20 23 21 22 86
Bowmore 15 21 22 22 21 86
Dewars 12 19 23 22 22 86
Glenfarclas 17 21 22 22 21 86
Glenfarclas 21 21 23 21 21 86
White & Mackay Glasgow Old Luxury 21Y 22 22 20 22 86
Bowmore 18 22 21 20 22 85
Dewars Signature 21 21 22 21 85
Live Botteling Longmorn 22 22 20 21 85
Live Botteling Port Ellen 23 18 22 22 85
Nikka Red 22 20 22 21 85
Nikka White 21 22 23 19 85
Edradour Straight From The Cask Madeira Finish 22 19 22 21 84
Talisker 10 22 21 21 20 84
Glengoyne 15 21 21 21 20 83
Glenmorangie Lasanta 21 21 21 20 83
Labrot & Graham Woodford Reserve 20 23 21 19 83
Nikka Black 20 20 21 22 83
Talisker DE 20 21 21 21 83
Oban 14 20 21 21 20 82
Glengoyne 12 21 20 20 19 80
Glenkinchie 12 22 19 20 19 80
White & Mackay Glasgow Old Luxury 19Y 21 20 19 20 80
Glen Grant 1800 19 21 20 19 79
Glengoyne 17 19 20 20 19 78
Edradour Straight From The Cask Cote de Prevance 19 20 15 13 67
Caperdonnich 10Y (Sigantory) 18 15 16 15 64
Schots-Ierse Dag - Vroenhoven (28/09/2008)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Glendullan 23Y 1974 Rare Malt Selection 22 24 23 24 93
Isle Of Jura 1989 Scott's Selection 22 23 23 23 91
Glen Scotia 1992 The Ultimate 22 23 22 22 89
Tullibardine 1989 Scott's Selection 22 22 23 22 89
Balblair 1975 24 23 23 23 93
Glengoyne 16Y Glenguin Chiraz Cask Finish 24 24 24 24 96
Glengoyne 17Y 23 24 22 23 92
Glengoyne 21Y 23 24 23 24 94
Glengoyne 12Y 24 23 24 24 95
Glengoyne 10Y 22 22 22 22 88
Glenmorangie Astar 23 24 24 23 94
Balvenie 15Y Single Barrel 23 22 23 23 91
Lagavulin 12Y 1995 Excl. Friend Of Classic Malt 24 24 24 24 96
Glenfiddich 12Y Coaran 22 22 22 23 89
Coal Ila 1984 Scott's Selection 23 24 23 23 93
Clubtasting Speyside - Vroenhoven (18/10/2008)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Macduff 17Y Exclusive Malts 24 24 24 23 95
Balvenie Portwood 1993 23 24 23 23 93
Mortlach 17Y 1989 Signatory Refill Butt 22 23 22 23 90
Mannochmore 1991 Signatory African Sherry 22 23 21 23 89
Tamdhu 8Y Gordon & Macphails 22 22 22 22 88
Monkey Shoulder 21 22 20 21 84
Spirits In The Sky - Leuven (09/11/2008)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Balvenie 17Y Sherry Oak 24 24 24 24 96
Laphroiag 25Y 25 24 24 23 96
Port Charlotte 7 23 24 24 24 95
Benriach 21Y 24 23 24 24 95
Yamazaki The Cask Of Yamazaki 1993 Heavily Peated 23 23 25 24 95
Finlaggan Cask Strength 23 24 24 24 95
Springbank 15Y old bottling 23 24 23 23 93
Macduff 19Y 1963 Connoisseurs Choice 23 24 24 22 93
White Bowmore 1964 24 24 23 22 93
Port Ellen 8th Release 24 23 23 23 93
Springbank 10Y 24 22 23 23 92
Longrow 14Y 24 23 22 22 91
Tullibardine Sauterne Finish 23 23 22 22 90
Glenrothes 1985 23 23 23 20 89
Glenmorangie Signet 22 23 22 22 89
Auchentoshan 18Y 21 22 23 21 87
Glenrothes 1994 22 23 22 19 86
Hazelburn 8Y 22 20 21 22 85
Ardbeg Blasda 23 23 20 19 85
Glen Garioch 15Y 23 21 20 19 83
The Glengarry Whiskypub - Gent (31/01/2009)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Dalmore 17Y Signatory First Fill Sherry Butt 1990 23 23 23 24 93
Bowmore 17Y Old Label 24 23 23 23 93
Ardbeg 17Y 24 23 23 24 94
Arran 12Y 22 22 23 23 90
Bunnuhabhain 10Y Signatory Heavely Peated 1997 24 21 22 23 90
Laphroaig 18Y Signatory Bourbon Barrel 1990 24 23 23 23 93
Bruichladdich Octomore 24 24 24 24 96
Kilchoman 25 22 20 24 91
Isle Of Jura Heavely Peated 23 23 23 23 92
Ardbeg Still Young 23 23 23 22 91
Talisker Distillers Edition 24 24 24 22 94
Bruichladdich 16Y Bourbon Cask 23 24 24 22 93
Ledaig 10Y 22 23 23 24 92
A Gentlemen's Experience - Diest (08/02/2009)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Laphroaig Quarter Cask 24 24 24 23 95
Macallan Speymalt 1999 (Gordon & MacPhail) 24 23 24 23 94
Glengoyne Cask Strength 12 Years Old 24 20 23 24 91
Penderyn Single Malt 23 22 23 22 90
Glenmorangie Burgundy Wood Finish 20 23 23 21 87
The Celt Irish Pub - Diest (08/02/2009)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Bunnahabhain 27Y Signatory Refill Butt 1978 24 24 24 23 95
Caperdonich Reserve 23Y Gordon & MacPhail 24 24 24 23 95
Glenfiddich 15Y Cask Strength 23,5 23 24 24 94,5
Glenfiddich 1991 Vintage Reserve 22,5 23 24 21 90,5
Whiskyfestival - Gent (15/02/2009)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Ledaig 32Y Chieftain's 1973 Hoghshead 24 25 24 24 97
Laphroaig 40Y 24 25 24 24 97
Brora 75 Platinum Old & Rare Selection 23 25 25 24 97
Banff 23Y Chieftain's 1979 23 24 25 24 96
Balblair 65 24 24 24 23 95
Macallan 25Y Fine Oak 24 24 24 23 95
Finlaggan Cask Strength 24 24 23 24 95
Bunnahabhain 16Y Manzanilla Finish 23 23 24 24 94
Bunnahabhain 25Y 23 23 25 23 94
Convalmore 30Y Dun Bheagan 1975 Hoghshead 24 24 24 22 94
Finlaggan Old Reserve 23 23 24 24 94
Tomantin 30Y 23 25 22 23 93
Infinity Bruichladdich 23 24 23 23 93
Ledaig 31Y Signatory 74 Hoghshead 23 22 24 23 92
Glenkinchie 20Y 24 22 22 23 91
Glenrothes 1991 21 24 24 22 91
Hakushu 18Y 22 24 22 23 91
Glen Elgin 16Y 24 24 20 21 89
Tomintoul 16Y 23 22 22 22 89
Balmenach 17Y Single Malts Of Scotland 21 23 22 23 89
Scapa 16Y 22 23 22 22 89
Benriach 16Y Sauterne finish 21 22 22 22 87
Glen Farclas 21Y 22 22 21 21 86
Glenrothes 1994 20 23 22 21 86
Benriach 12Y 20 21 19 23 83
Whisky Live - Spa (14/03/2009)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Glenfarclas Family Cask 1960 Cask 1768 Sherry Hogshead 24,5 25 25 24,5 99
Glenfarclas Family Cask 1973 Cask 2578 Sherry Butt 25 23,5 24,5 24,5 97,5
Glenfarclas Family Cask 1972 Cask 3546 Sherry Butt 24 24 25 24 97
Glenfarclas Family Cask 1967 Cask 5117 Sherry Hogshead 24 24 24,5 24,5 97
St Magdalene 19Y Rare Malts 24,5 23 24,5 25 97
Laphroaig 25Y 24,5 24 24 24 96,5
Ardbeg Uigedail 24,5 23,5 24 23,5 95,5
Caol Ila 12Y Smoke On The Water La Maison Du Whisky 24 23,5 23,5 24 95
Bowmore 1994 Berry Bros 24 23,5 23 24,5 95
Nikka Coffee Malt 12Y 23 24 23,5 24 94,5
Glenfiddich 15Y 24 23,5 23,5 23,5 94,5
Macallan Masters Edition 23 24 24 23 94
Aberlour 18Y 23 24 23,5 23,5 94
Laphroaig 10Y Cask Strength 24 23,5 23,5 23 94
Ardbeg Airigh Nam Beist 23,5 23,5 24 23 94
Laphroaig 7Y Signatory 2001 Refill Butt 23 24,5 23 23,5 94
Bladnoch 18Y 23 24 23,5 23 93,5
Jura 18Y 23 24 23,5 23 93,5
Arran Madeira Wine Cask 24 23 23 23 93
Clynelish 12Y Signatory 1995 Sherry Butt 24,5 22 23 23,5 93
White & Mackay 30Y 24 24 22 23 93
Glenfarclas 30Y 23 24 23 23 93
Glenmorangie Astar 23,5 24 22 23 92,5
Jura Heavily Peated 24,5 23,5 22 22,5 92,5
Bruichladdich 2001 23,5 22,5 23 23 92
Craigellachie Les Bonbons La Maison Du Whisky 23 23 23 23 92
Bunnahabhain 10Y Heavily Peated Signatory 1997 22 22 24 23 91
Linkwood 18Y Signatory 1990 Hogshead 23,5 23 22 22 90,5
Dalmore 15Y 23 23 23,5 21 90,5
Oban De 1992 24,5 23 22 21 90,5
Glengoyne 17Y 22,5 22,5 23 22 90
Glenrothes 14Y Signatory 1994 Refill Butt 23 22 22 22 89
Arran St Emilion 23 22,5 21 22 88,5
Glen Ord 10Y Signatory 1998 Hogshead 23,5 21 21 23 88,5
Aberfeldy 21Y 23 22 22 20 87
Arran 1996 Fixen Wood Finish 22,5 22 21 21 86,5
Port Ellen 26Y Berry Bros 1982 23 22 21,5 20 86,5
Glenmorangie 18Y Extremely Rare 22,5 22,5 21 20 86
Dewars 18Y 22,5 21 22,5 19,5 85,5
Wild West Whisky Fest - Kortrijk (06/06/2009)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Ardbeg Kildalton 24,5 24,5 25 24,5 98,5
Dalmore 1973 Gonzales Byass Finish 24 24 25 24 97
St Magdalene 1982 Berry Bros 24 24 24 24,5 96,5
Oat Mint 43Y Daily Dram 24 25 24 23 96
Highland Park 11Y Single Cask 25 24 23 24 96
Tomatin 40Y 24 24 24 24 96
Tullibardine 1965 24 24 23,5 24 95,5
Tullibardine 1973 22 24 24 23 93
Caperdonich 1968 Part Des Agnes 24 24 22 23 93
Auk's Choir 34Y Daily Dram 24 23 23 22,5 92,5
The Balvenie 17Y New Wood 23 23,5 23,5 22 92
Benriach 1988 Virgin Wood 23 25 22 22 92
Ileach Cask Strength 23 22,5 23 23,5 92
Banff 26Y Sherry Wood Chieftain's Choice 24 23 22 22 91
Rosebank 18Y Sherry Butt Chieftain's Choice 22,5 21 23 22,5 89
Amrut Cask Strength 22 22 22 22 88
Royal Brackla 10Y 1998 VCWC Festival Bottling 22 22 21 22 87
Benriach 15Y Pedro Ximinez 22,5 20 21 22,5 86
Schots-Ierse Dag - Vroenhoven (20/09/2009)
NAAM Body Nose Taste Finish Score
Glenmorangie Lasanta 23 22 23 19 87
Balblair 89 21 22 24 22 89
Balblair 97 22 21 21 21 85
Glengoyne 17Y 22 23 23 23 91
Springbank 100° Proof 24 23 22,5 22 91,5
Balvenie 17y Madeira Cask 22,5 22 20 21 85,5
Glen Elgin 16Y Cask Strength 23 23,5 23,5 22 92
Tullibardine Moscatel Finish 21 23,5 23,5 22,5 90,5
Balvenie 30y 23,5 23 24,5 25 96
Tullibardine Vintage 1975 24 23 24 24 95
Hazelburn 8Y 21 22 22 20 85